“Do not be afraid. You can only benefit.” – Insights “From Insights to Impact” conference

The Public Engagement for Energy Infrastructure Task contributed to the conference “From Insights to Impact: Behavioral and Policy Research for Environmental Health”, jointly organised by the OneHealth Platform and Fraunhofer ISI, with a talk on policy acceptance and a World Café on public voices in socio-ecological transitions.

How can behavioural and social science insights be turned into real-world policy impact? That question ran through “From Insights to Impact”, which brought together researchers and practitioners working on health, environment and behaviour. The Task took on two roles: Diana Süsser (IEECP, Lead of the Public Engagement Task) presented the Task’s research in the session on policy acceptance, and hosted a World Café on public voices in socio-ecological transitions. Although the conference focused on environmental health rather than energy infrastructure, many contributions resonated strongly with the Task’s work.

From acceptance to engagement

Day two opened with a gallery walk, where researchers and practitioners exchanged views on different initiatives for transferring research into policy and practice. A policy panel then asked what makes research actionable, followed by a session on making research policy-relevant. Along the way, two tools stood out: Policy Ultra Briefs (PUBs), a format for communicating research to policymakers effectively, and Klimarolle, a climate role-play from Denmark that makes policy choices tangible.

In the session on policy acceptance, Diana Süsser argued for moving from asking whether people accept a technology to asking how, when and on what terms they want to be involved. The argument drew on the Task’s survey and interviews on hydrogen, carbon capture utilisation and storage (CCUS) and advanced nuclear. The other talks in the session, and the policy panel, approached the same issue from different angles.

One study used simulations to show how effective a policy is. Simulations and plain information performed about equally well, and both raised acceptance compared with the control group. The lesson: what matters is how people engage with information, not simply that they receive it.

This led to a related question: how simple can a message get and still be honest? Participants discussed clear, simple, easy-to-understand messages, the balance between emotions and facts, and the importance of being upfront about what is known and what is not. It was also seen as critical to define a clear target group, and spend more time understanding those who do not want a policy, not only those who already agree.

Several contributions stressed that acceptance is not just a communication problem. It is about power, and about who gains and who loses. Hence, was seen as critically to name the co-benefits explicitly: X can also contribute to Y.

Discussions on individual versus system change highlighted how inequalities in wealth and infrastructure limit the behavioural choices people actually have.

Public voices for One Health

The World Café organised by Diana Süsser took its own course, as good ones do. At the formats table, participants discussed their experiences with different engagement formats, including websites, social media, referendums, focus groups, citizens’ councils and co-creation. The trade-offs were familiar but sharply put. Websites share ideas widely, but it matters who sends the message. Focus groups bring people in, though often only when participants are paid. Citizens’ councils bring new perspectives and everyday-life challenges into view, but they take time and money. Co-creation leads to more suitable interventions and more trust in the process and its outcomes.

One tension ran through the discussion: informing people versus giving them real choices. Researchers came up repeatedly as messengers often perceived as trusted and neutral, which raises the question of what their role should be.

At the table on engagement principles, five themes emerged. Transparency about one’s role, the intended outcome and what will happen with the results. Roles and responsibilities of researchers and of others, such as industry, including openness about conflicts of interest. Openness, for example by co-defining engagement principles with the public and not overlooking existing local initiatives. Inclusiveness: who is part of the debate, who is at the table who should not be, and a willingness to face different perspectives. And context: understanding the local context first, and letting methods follow the intended outcome.

Key messages for policymakers

The World Café closed by asking participants for one key message to policymakers about involving the public. Their answers:

  • Do not be afraid. You can only benefit.
  • Be honest, and be transparent about what influence the results can have.
  • Institutionalise engagement for the long run.
  • Establish more forms of direct democracy and a functioning transparency law.
  • Apply diverse formats to include diverse perspectives.

    What the Public Engagement Task carries forward

    These messages came from people working on health, environment and behaviour, not necessarily energy infrastructure. Yet they closely match what the Task is hearing in its own work on emerging energy technologies. That convergence is reassuring: across sectors, the call is for public engagement that is honest, inclusive and built to last. The Task will feed the presentation feedback and World Café results into its guidelines on public engagement for emerging energy technologies.

    The Task thanks everyone who joined the session and the World Café, and the organisers for creating space for exchange across disciplines.